Why does WordPress treat spam comments nicer than other moderated comments?

I think I just accidentally deleted a comment in WordPress moderation. The irony struck me, that if I had accidentally marked it as spam, then I could have rescued it from the Spam queue.

WordPress lead developer Mark Jaquith has proposed adding Undo functionality which I think is very important!

Mark says this idea was inspired by Robert Hoekman, Jr. book Designing the Obvious, but today I see this may have already been germinated with WordPress Idea: ‘Replace “dumb-user” confirmation dialogs by GMail-like Undo links‘.

Would the trash metaphor also be useful for deleted posts and comments? I didn’t find any related ideas, so maybe it is just me. I wonder, but I think the first gate is getting undo functionality.


11 thoughts on “Why does WordPress treat spam comments nicer than other moderated comments?

  1. I suggested this one around last year, the first time I accidentally deleted something. It makes sense to me that it would just go to a recycle bin thing and you could republish it later.

    At least the link on delete post turns red now. That could be a quick add-on for delete comment if it doesn’t already do it.

  2. I hope this gets taken care of by the time I switch over… Deleting useful things definitely sounds like something I’d do.

  3. That is a great idea! I have done the same thing several times with my junk mail box. As I am going through it instead of hitting that delete button, I hit the empty botton and everything is gone. Plus there is no undo button so if there was anything incorrectly sorted as junk mail, it is forever gone.

  4. I would be a good ideas for the undo function. Sometime, I really wrong deleted some comment that are not spam. Human always make mistake. :P

  5. Every program should have an undo option. It certain would have save me a lot of grief. I’m not aware of any PHP scripts that have this feature. I’m not sure how it would be done, but I’m not a coder, just a fiddle around with the code-er :)

  6. I accidentally delete comments all the time! Maybe I should get in the habit of marking them as spam instead…?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>